I have become a real bore at parties. (Ok. True confession: I’ve always been a bore at parties, but I’ve recently upped my game.) I can’t stop observing and commenting on the ways that our educational system lets down kids that are different-minded or out-of-sync with their peers.
If a child’s development is out-of-sync with their peers, it matters.
If it’s really out of sync it REALLY matters.
I told you: single-minded bore.
While it seems to be all I talk about some days, I hadn’t even heard the phrase “asynchronous development” until a few years ago, when my now seven-year-old son was four, and my wife and I were trying to figure out what to do about kindergarten. While we support public schools, our local one was near failing. So, we were exploring our options and had found a couple of schools we liked.
I assumed all that was required to satisfy a kid’s educational needs was supportive parents, high-quality teachers, and a school with decent resources. School is, by nature, boring. Get used to it. Whatever weaknesses a school has can be compensated for later.
I had completely forgotten my own troubled history in one of California’s best public school systems (back in the 60’s when California’s schools were the envy of the nation). Or, rather, the experience had been so mortifying that I had intentionally put it out of my mind–it was a period of esteem-challenging extended personal failure I’d still rather forget.
Then, I met Anne Beneventi. Thank goodness. After meeting my then four-year-old son as part of the application process to a local private school (an interview that turned into an extended monologue about superheroes and ninjas), she asked to speak with us and introduced us to the concept of asynchronous development and the consequences of failing to be mindful of it.
I was skeptical and told her so. She handed me a paper about the tension between socialization (conforming to the group) and being true to yourself (social development) when a child is out of sync with with their peers.
When I read it, I cried. I handed it to my wife who also teared up. I felt like the paper was written about me. My wife felt like it described her school experience.
I realized for the first time that my transformation from kindergarten-loving, gap-toothed kid to sullen eighth-grader lying under a blanket on the floor of my mother’s station wagon on the way to the lock-up ward of a local psychiatric hospital was an extreme but foreseeable consequence of unaddressed asynchronous development.
You see. Here’s the thing:
Not all kids are the same.
They don’t grow at identical rates. They don’t learn at identical rates. While most kids grow and develop at similar rates, there are outliers that develop at a very different rate from the norm. And therein lies the rub. There are kids, though quite rare, that start reading on their own at 2 or 3 or perform multi-digit multiplication and division in their head by age five.
One thing seems obvious (but apparently it’s not because most schools and most teacher training live in denial of it): when you stick a kid in a classroom based on what year the kid was born rather than on what the kid knows or can do, things can go wrong, sometimes terribly wrong, if the kid’s development is significantly out-of-sync with their classmates’.
Imagine a five-year-old who has gone from reading Hop on Pop to The Hobbit in less than a year and speaks with the vocabulary of an eleven-year-old. Or, imagine a kid the same age who is teaching him or herself algebra and geometry while their classmates are learning to add and subtract single-digit numbers. When these kids try to communicate with their age-mates about the subjects of their greatest enthusiasm, they are often greeted by bewildered looks and blank stares.
In the majority of school districts, these kids will be trapped for years in classrooms that have nothing to offer them. While their classmates are getting the opportunity to learn, they are denied the opportunity. They are stuck filling out worksheets far below their skill level. They are stuck sitting in classes for hours a day watching other kids get a chance to learn.
Not only are they bored, but they are surrounded by classmates that don’t relate to them or share their interests or passions — classmates may find them freakish or weird which in turn may make them think of themselves as freakish and weird. They may try to fit in by hiding who they are, and if they do, since who they are isn’t going to go away, they may eventually find themselves in crisis.
A child does not have to be as out-of-sync as the aforementioned kids for a host of negative consequences to kick in…eventually. A child need be only just out-of-sync enough that the classroom does not engage them, just out-of-sync enough that school is a daily bore. In some ways, such kids are the most at-risk. Their asynchrony goes unnoticed, and everything seems fine until suddenly it’s not. These consequences are largely avoidable by acknowledging that these kids exist and have the same right to learn as their more-typical age-mates.
On Minds On Fire, I’ll be looking at asynchronous learners, their needs and how to meet those needs from a variety of perspectives as well as looking at related topics in neuroscience, pedagogy, psychology, public policy and more.
Next up will be Asynchronous Learners and the Right to Learn. Stay tuned!
True Confessions by Edward Spiegel is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
19 thoughts on “True Confessions”
Great post Edward.
Looking forward to future posts; learning more.
Thank you Edward! We look forward to hearing more…
I really enjoyed this. Please put me on the list to learn more.
Thanks for the kind words. I need to figure out a why to notify people. In the meantime, if you Like the Facebook page (http://facebook.com/mindsonfireblog) or subscribe to the Twitter feed (see the link in the left column) you will be notified. If you have a feed reader, the RSS feeds will do the trick. So much that I need to learn about the whole blogging thing!
Joanne, I’ve add a subscribe by email option. Scroll down far enough and you will find the new Subscribe by Email button.
Thank you for this and especially for the link to the paper.
You nailed it. Painfully descriptive and beautifully written portrayal of asynchronous learners. Nice job.
Thank you, Gail. I just read your piece http://www.giftedchallenges.blogspot.com/2015/09/supporting-your-emotionally-excitable.html
An important topic.
Edward, this is great. I’m really proud and happy that you took this step and can convey this important information in a way that is accessible, relatable , understandable and meaningful. Looking forward to more!
I don’t see “like” symbol, Edward 🙂
OK, reading your blog I can see that our experiences are pretty the same, be in USA or Serbia. Text is 3D touch sensitive 🙂
Excellent post! I am very much looking forward to reading your future posts. Thank you for speaking out on your personal experiences about giftedness and asynchronous development. Way too many educators and society as a whole do not understand giftedness. The more of us who speak out and relay our personal experiences, the more likely we can bring about a better understanding. So glad you are joining in the conversation to shed light on what giftedness really is!
Thank you! Glad to be here. Now…..back to writing 🙂
Edward, thanks for writing this. Many of us had these experiences as kids because there wasn’t a better way. Our own children deserve better.
Thanks, Rob. I’d love to chat about your childhood and education at some point. I’m hoping that by sharing our experiences, we might be able to help some people find their way and make sense of their own experience. Not everyone is lucky enough to have crossed paths with Anne B!
Great post. Asynchrony has been beautiful to watch on my young child while fiercely trying to shield him from the negativity and the pressure to conform to the norm, protect his self-esteem. So far we have survived it and he is soaring, but I more than often feel exhausted with such task. Thank you for advocating through your blog and personal experience for our gifted children.
Thank you for the appreciation. Parenting such active minds is a daily challenge! and reward!